Pennsylvania Dutch Mystery
10 books
Here are 10 books from the Pennsylvania Dutch Mystery series by Tamar Myers. Start with Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth (1995), then read the rest in the order below.
Books in order
Too Many Crooks Spoil the Broth
Tamar Myers
When a seemingly routine gathering turns deadly, an astute Pennsylvania Dutch innkeeper finds herself drawn into a tangled mystery where everyone appears to have something to hide. As suspicion simmers through the close-knit community, she must sort genuine clues from local rivalries, family secrets, and a generous helping of red herrings. Blending homespun humor, colorful characters, and clever plotting, this cozy mystery explores the complications of community life—and proves that too many suspects can make one very dangerous broth.
Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Crime
Tamar Myers
When Mennonite innkeeper Magdalena Yoder agrees to let a Hollywood film crew use her peaceful PennDutch Inn, the promise of easy money and glamour quickly gives way to trouble. After a crew member is murdered, Magdalena finds herself drawn into a dangerous investigation—and uncomfortably close to the center of suspicion. Blending cozy mystery, Pennsylvania Dutch culture, and wry humor, the novel follows a determined amateur sleuth as she works to uncover the truth without sacrificing her community’s quiet way of life.
No Use Dying over Spilled Milk
Tamar Myers
When an unexpected death unsettles a close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community, an amateur sleuth is drawn into an investigation where old grudges, family secrets, and local rivalries refuse to stay buried. Balancing sharp observation with wry humor, she navigates a world shaped by tradition, faith, and fiercely held opinions while searching for the truth. This engaging cozy mystery blends clever detection, colorful characters, and an affectionate portrait of small-town life.
Just Plain Pickled to Death
Tamar Myers
When a shocking death disrupts the close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community, amateur sleuth Magdalena Yoder finds herself drawn into a mystery as tangled as the local gossip. Surrounded by eccentric neighbors, long-buried secrets, and deeply held traditions, Magdalena must rely on her sharp instincts and determination to uncover the truth. Blending cozy-mystery suspense with lively humor and an affectionate portrait of Mennonite and Pennsylvania Dutch culture, this entertaining installment offers a distinctive and flavorful whodunit.
Between a Wok and a Hard Place
Tamar Myers
When a murder disrupts the close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community, sharp-tongued sleuth Magdalena Yoder finds herself caught between conflicting clues, eccentric suspects, and local expectations. Her investigation leads through a lively world of family loyalties, community gossip, and culinary traditions, where appearances can be as deceptive as motives. Blending gentle humor, richly drawn characters, and classic whodunit intrigue, this cozy mystery explores faith, friendship, and the complications of seeking justice in a community where everyone seems to know everyone else.
Eat, Drink, and Be Wary
Tamar Myers
When a suspicious death disrupts the close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community of Hernia, Mennonite innkeeper and amateur sleuth Magdalena Yoder finds herself drawn into another baffling investigation. As she follows a trail of secrets, rivalries, and questionable motives, Magdalena must rely on her sharp wit and intimate knowledge of local customs to uncover the truth. Blending culinary charm, gentle satire, and classic cozy-mystery intrigue, the novel explores community life, tradition, faith, and the complications of seeking justice among friends and neighbors.
The Hand That Rocks the Ladle
Tamar Myers
In a close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community, a seemingly ordinary culinary gathering takes a sinister turn when murder disrupts the local routine. As an amateur sleuth investigates, old grudges, hidden motives, and community secrets begin to surface behind the region’s warm hospitality and traditional cooking. Blending homespun humor, colorful characters, and a carefully crafted mystery, this cozy whodunit explores friendship, family, and the complications of small-town life.
The Crepes of Wrath
Tamar Myers
When a tempting French dessert is served alongside a shocking murder, antiques dealer Abigail Timberlake finds herself drawn into another dangerous investigation. As she follows a trail through the worlds of rare collectibles, hidden motives, and Charleston society, Abigail must distinguish genuine clues from carefully crafted deceptions. Blending clever mystery, Southern atmosphere, quirky characters, and lighthearted humor, this entertaining cozy whodunit explores greed, betrayal, and the perilous secrets concealed behind beautiful objects.
Gruel and Unusual Punishment
Tamar Myers
When an unexpected death unsettles the close-knit Pennsylvania Dutch community of Hernia, Indiana, irrepressible chief of police Magdalena Yoder finds herself drawn into another unsettling investigation. Surrounded by eccentric neighbors, hidden resentments, and more culinary intrigue than anyone could digest, Magdalena must sort rumor from evidence before the killer strikes again. Blending cozy mystery, sharp social observation, and signature Amish-country humor, this lively whodunit explores community loyalty, family secrets, and the surprising dangers lurking beneath small-town respectability.
Assault and Pepper
Tamar Myers
When an antiques dealer’s ordinary routine is disrupted by a shocking murder, she finds herself drawn into a case where valuable objects, hidden grudges, and dangerous secrets collide. As she follows a trail of suspicious clues, she must rely on her sharp instincts—and a healthy dose of courage—to distinguish genuine evidence from clever deception. Blending witty dialogue, eccentric characters, and classic whodunit suspense, this cozy mystery explores the perils of greed, the complexities of loyalty, and the surprising connections tucked away in everyday communities.